Subscribe to Amy's Newsletter

IRLF: Child Labor, Union Negotiations on Flower Farms

Posted by on September 14, 2006 in Cut Flowers | 6 comments

Thanks to the International Labor Rights Fund for sending on news of two labor issues on Latin American flower farms.  Before I get into this, let me just remind you that there are some excellent certification programs that can help ensure that the flowers you buy met some standards of social and environmental responsibility.  There are important differences between those programs, which I discuss here and in greater detail in Flower Confidential

Now, on to the news:

This story in El Comercio, Quito’s daily newspaper, reports on a new study from Ecuador’s ministry of labor and employment about child labor on a variety of farms, including flower farms.  The article’s in Spanish, but here’s the bottom line: 

The investigation covered 595 farms and employers.  Roughly 10% of the farms were found to have some child labor.  Overall, 88 children were found working on farms.  60% were between the ages of 15 and 17, and 40% were under 15 years old.  (Ecuador’s labor laws do allow kids age 15 and older to work with some limitations, but there were violations found based on those limitations.)

The flower farms that were found to be in violation of the law included Nevaflor, Lindaflor, Florana Farms, and Sunlight Farms.  None of these farms have been certified through VeriFlora or Ecuador’s program Flor del Ecuador.  The PR manager for Ecuador’s flower grower association, Expoflores, said that he was pleased that they had been sanctioned.  He went on to say that child labor affects the image of the entire floriculture sector.  (I met with officials from Expoflores when I was in Ecuador researching the book, and it is clear that they are very sincere about wanting their growers to meet the highest possible standards so that buyers continue to demand Ecuadorian flowers.)

Now on to another alert from IRLF, this time concerning the right of workers on Dole flower farms in Colombia to organize.  Go here to read more and to send a note to Dole.  Workers on two farms have been attempting to form a union for two years, but, according to the press release, Dole has used various tactics to block their attempts.  As IRLF staff have pointed out to me, giving the workers the right to unionize is one thing, but very few flower farms are actually successful at forming a union.  As you can imagine, it’s hard for workers to get the word out about problems they encounter, especially when the products they make are mostly shipped out of the country for sale abroad.  IRLF does a good job of giving voice to those workers, so please consider supporting them, and remember to ask about certified flowers when you go shopping.

6 Comments

  1. I have found it very difficult to get information about where flowers come from from florists here in the UK – an exception is an Edinburgh based florist Monica Higgins http://www.flowersbymonicahiggins.co.uk who sources some of her flowers from Cornwall.
    Where I have asked about Fair Trade or other certified flowers I have just got blank looks. I wonder whether some of the florists don’t want to think about any of the negative issues associated with producing flowers and therefore don’t investigate any alternatives or even bring the subject up with their suppliers.
    I would like to have a list of florists to give to my customers in the winter season when I don’t sell cut flowers but so far I haven’t found anyone who is prepared to guarantee where their flowers come from or how they are produced.
    What happens with Wiggly bouquets during the winter?

  2. My Dear
    Sir I am Umesh Chndra sahoo an ADVOCATE from Orissa ,INDIA Bar Council Enrolment No O-1127/19.04.2003 PAN NO- AWUPS4282J.I AM PROFFESSIONALLY A ADVOCATE I have constructed a Organization. in Orissa named “NAYA DARSAN “.which is totally dedicated to Child Labour and Women’s ,Sex workers Protection in INDIA I am sorry to inform that I am unable to run it due to lack of fund .so I am sending letters to every where .i have a hope any one can help me a little I don’t like to take a huge amount I need a few amount which will help full me please think u are losing many things but people are not getting right justice I can help them .all are human as a human I am begging for my orissa I need help only pls HEPL ME HEPL ME
    HEPL ME HEPL ME……………………………………………………
    GOD WILL HELP U
    THANKING U
    UMESH SAHOO
    Any body interested to give me donation pls send DD OR CHEQUE in favour of
    CONTACT NO-091-9238532069
    UMESH CHANDRA SAHOO
    C/O-M.KSWAIN
    A/141
    KOELNAGAR
    ROURKELA
    ORISSA
    INDIA

  3. (UMESH SAHOO)
    My Dear
    Sir I am Umesh Chndra sahoo an ADVOCATE from Orissa ,INDIA Bar Council Enrolment No O-1127/19.04.2003 PAN NO- AWUPS4282J.I AM PROFFESSIONALLY A ADVOCATE I have constructed a Organization. in Orissa named “NAYA DARSAN “.which is totally dedicated to Child Labour and Women’s ,Sex workers Protection in INDIA I am sorry to inform that I am unable to run it due to lack of fund .so I am sending letters to every where .i have a hope any one can help me a little I don’t like to take a huge amount I need a few amount which will help full me please think u are losing many things but people are not getting right justice I can help them .all are human as a human I am begging for my orissa I need help only pls HEPL ME HEPL ME
    HEPL ME HEPL ME……………………………………………………
    GOD WILL HELP U
    THANKING U
    UMESH SAHOO
    Any body interested to give me donation pls send DD OR CHEQUE in favour of
    CONTACT NO-091-9238532069
    UMESH CHANDRA SAHOO
    C/O-M.KSWAIN
    A/141
    KOELNAGAR
    ROURKELA
    ORISSA
    INDIA

  4. Use Involve,through play speech leader academic sure right together record will cut full congress effort distribution consequence hour these father reach class industry difficult convention sell author chair upon narrow number garden noise difference past direct long progress characteristic beginning chairman ring account largely eventually call series that rule drink assembly combine right maintain scientist definition last budget sun ignore partly animal and rural apart conduct mark property construction clear single such for sale need gas rely official figure neck fund lip be city get definition prove